Question concerning Progesterone...
January 28 2008 at 5:15 AM JadeGreen (Login JadeGreen)
So with all this talk about progesterone cream... As I'm low on progesterone, I was wondering if you could mix progesterone cream with herbs. If so... what's safe and what's not. Thanks!
Bere
(Login Berengere)
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
January 28 2008, 5:36 AM
Don't mix the progesterone cream with herbs since the purpose of the cream is to lower your estrogen levels and increase your progesterone, balancing your hormones and allowing the breasts to grow and fill out. Taking estrogenic herbs while trying to accomplish this defeats the purpose.
You want to either stick to the increase estrogen route, or the increase progesterone route, or you might really mess your hormones up. Most girls have been doing the increase estrogen route for breast enhancement, but increasing progesterone may be far more effective.
Apparently estrogen is mostly responsible for fat gain from the waist down, however it does contribue some to breast growth which explains why some do experience growth on estrogenic herbs. But progesterone is mainly responsible for fat gain from the waist up, especially breast growth.
We'll need some more people to test the progesterone route
Anyone else besides me?
Henri
(Login henriettahippo)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
January 28 2008, 12:08 PM
Don't use the progesterone unless you really need it. Do a search in the forum, and you will find some interesting articles, mostly the ones by Waxingmoon. In some cases progesterone causes breast growth, but not in every case. I for one have had no increase from progesterone, but am not disappointed as I didn't start it for breast growth, and am not doing any NBE routine currently.
If you do need progesterone, then I would recommend giving it a good couple of months (six at least) on its own, before adding in anything else. Otherwise neither will be working properly.
This message has been edited by henriettahippo on Jan 28, 2008 8:19 PM
JadeGreen
(Login JadeGreen)
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
January 29 2008, 3:00 AM
Thanks so much! I was a bit confused there. anyways I think i might just stick to the herbs since it's only been about 2 months since i started. I will definitely give progesterone a chance if the herbs don't work.
HAPPY GROWING!!! =)
Beth
(Login Boobsrock4life)
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
January 29 2008, 6:06 AM
I tried the progesteron cream and believe it or not it shrinked my boobs, I think progesterone from the wild yam is not good for NBE because it somehow interfers with the one your body produces and also prolactin. However, I think some certain kind of progestins that are synthetic for BC are effective for NBE, but this is not always the best route.
waxingmoon
(Login waxingmoon)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
January 29 2008, 6:53 PM
Hey, just wanted to add my two cents here...
Beth, unless the wild yam has been processed in a lab then there is absolutely no progesterone from it. When they process wild yam, the lab will create a progesterone molecule that is exactly like the one our body produces. It does not interfere with our body's progesterone, it adds to it.
Now artificial progestins on the other hand are not like our progesterone molecules. They most closely resemble testosterone molecules. Progestins will attach to progesterone receptors, but they do not provide the same effects as the natural progesterone our bodies produce - or the manufactured USP grade progesterone that is created in the lab from wild yam.
Will progesterone cause your breasts to enlarge or to shrink?... it all depends. If you are estrogen dominant there may be a balancing of hormones from the use of progesterone cream and this can cause breast growth in some.
For others, the use of progesterone cream will balance the estrogen - and one of the effects of lowering high estrogen is to reduce the symptoms of estrogen dominance. One of the chief symptoms of estrogen dominance is swelling of the breasts, especially during the later phases of the menstrual cycle. Therefore, for some the use of progesterone will 'shrink' the breast because it reduces the excess estrogens swelling of the breast.
1. For some progesterone will cause a permanent increase in breast size.
2. For some progesterone will cause a reduction in breast swelling - thus a reduction in breast size.
3. For some there will be an initial increase of estrogen -since progesterone is used by the body to activate estrogen receptors and create estrogen. This would initially cause a swelling of the breast before the period which would then reduce during the period.
So.... as I have clearly outlined here... the answer to the question about whether progesterone will cause an increase in breast size is YES, NO and MAYBE.
clear as mud... lol
waxingmoon
hula girl
(Login 65hulagirl)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
January 29 2008, 11:58 PM
I am taking WU, but am also using Progesterone Cream as instructed on the bottle. I suffer from severe PMS. A friend had recommended it to me a while back. Then I read on the forum that it had the benefit of increasing your breast size. So, my question is, should I not be using the cream because I am on WU? But the cream helps with the PMS. Does it hurt to do both? Somebody please clarify. I'd hate to be doing both and having them cancel each ohter out.
Miles
(no login)
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
January 31 2008, 1:57 AM
I'm not exactly sure. But, i would think it would be okay, if you were cycling the progesterone because the body naturally has a higher influx of estrogen at the beginning of the cycle and then a drop in E and a higher influx of progesterone at the end of the cycle. So, as long as you didn't use it for the whole month, I would think it would be fine. But, I don't know for sure.
hopeful88
(Login Hopeful88)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
January 31 2008, 4:11 PM
Waxingmoon: you said "One of the chief symptoms of estrogen dominance is swelling of the breasts, especially during the later phases of the menstrual cycle."
But I never in my life get before period swelling so wouldn't this imply that I'm not estrogen dominant? ah so confusing...
waxingmoon
(Login waxingmoon)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
January 31 2008, 5:34 PM
Hopeful,
It is not a matter of whether you have ALL of the symptoms of estrogen dominance but rather how many of the symptoms you have. The more you have the more likely it is that estrogen dominance plays a role in your body's distress.
Here is the list of estrogen dominance symptoms- copied from the book 'What your doctor may not tell you about premenopause' by Dr. John Lee (this makes probably the billionth time I have referenced this book on Eve' forum...lol)
Acceleration of the aging process
Allergy symptoms
Auto-immune disorders
Breast cancer
Breast tenderness
Cervical dysplasia
Cold hands and feet as a symptom of thyroid dysfunction
Copper excess
Decreased sex drive
Depression with anxiety or agitation
Dry eyes
Early onset of menstruation
Endometrial cancer
Fat gain -especially around the abdomen, hips and thighs
Fibrocystic breasts
Foggy thinking
Gallbladder disease
Hair loss
Headaches
Hypoglycemia
Increased blood clotting
Infertility
Irregular menstrual cycles
Irritability
Insomnia
Magnesium deficiency
Memory loss
Mood swings
Osteoporosis
PMS
Polycystic ovaries
Premenopausal bone loss
Prostate cancer (obviously this one is about men)
Sluggish metabolism
Thyroid dysfunction mimicking hypothyroidism
Uterine cancer
Uterine fibroids
Water retention, bloatiing
Zinc deficiency
Whew... that's a big list. And if you had ALL of those symptoms you would have to be a hermaphrodite because one of those symptoms is about prostate cancer... lol. However, the more symptoms you have on the list, the more likely it is you have estrogen dominance. And if you do think this is reflective of your physical state then you would be doing yourself a big favor to get that book I mentioned... and read it... and try some of the things the book suggests...
Some people go to the John Lee website where they have online questionaires that will basically point you in the same direction as this list.
And remember --- Your health is far more important than whether you ever accomplish your NBE goals. If you are using an herb or ovary program and begin to develop this list of symptoms then beware... Nobody is going to see your big old rack if you are sick in bed or worse yet pushing up daisies ---
Guard your health,
waxingmoon
hopeful88
(Login Hopeful88)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
January 31 2008, 10:45 PM
I do have several of those but they come and go... like the moodiness and anxiety I don't have those every day. However I am definitely a very nervous and anxious person... But since you suggest that one doesn't necessairly need to have all of the symptoms, I think I am going to try buy some today or tomorrow as I've been on a little stall test with my NBE pills and its the right time in my cycle right now.
If I can only buy one that is in a jar and is not a pump type of bottle how will I know how much to put on? just a tiny little dot on my finger will suffice? Do I need to put it on once or twice a day? thanks dear
This message has been edited by Hopeful88 on Jan 31, 2008 10:47 PM
Woolly Sheep
(Login Hopeful88)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 1 2008, 5:30 AM
Ok nevermind I went to 2 different health stores (including GNC) and couldn't find any ones that were USP grade.
Woolly Sheep
(no login)
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 1 2008, 1:10 PM
I bought my pc from an internet store (natural pc, usp grade) and it was really affordable. Cant remember who it was but it was recommended to me by someone on this site - the brand i'm using is the NOW pc. The total cost in cad was about $11.50...
Moon
(Login -Moon-)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 1 2008, 7:01 PM
What is USP grade?
Also a quation to the PC experts - is it possible that one would be progesterone defficient / estrogen dominant, but that the symptoms, especially PMS wouldn't express because of being on BCP? I've been on the pill sicne I was 15 and I don't remeber if I had PMS before that and if I did I probably wouldn't know it had anything to do with my periods. But when I went off the BCP a couple of years ago I got a really horrible PMS. But that could have been exaggerated by the sudden withdrawal of external hormones. I have a few symptoms of that list, but there are many those that you can't know if you have. I dunno if I have policystic ovaries. How could I know whether I'm prog. defficient / estrogen dominant or not at all?
Hopeful88
(Login Hopeful88)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 1 2008, 10:58 PM
it means that it reaches the United States Pharmacopeia standards and testing I believe...
waxingmoon
(Login waxingmoon)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 1 2008, 11:21 PM
Hi Moon,
The USP on the label of progesterone cream identifies the substance as being bio-identical to our body's natural progesterone. Those creams that do not have USP behind the progesterone in the ingredients label will not be useful as a progesterone supplement.
As far as your questions about estrogen dominance I would say if you have just one or two symptoms on the list then you may not be affected by this condition. You will notice the symptom list includes quite a lot of things that might be associated with other conditions (hypothyroidism for example). The term 'estrogen dominance' was coined by Dr. John Lee as a description of a wide variety of symptoms that coincided with a lack of progesterone and were relieved by the use of supplemental progesterone.
PMS might very well have been masked by the BCP because you would not have ovulated when on the pill and ovulation generally makes PMS worse.
Yes, without testing, some of those conditions like polycystic ovaries are impossible to know - but the symptoms of conditions might be present. If you do not have very many symptoms then maybe this is not the 'tag' for you.
I was without a doubt estrogen dominant. The list of symptoms was the first time I ran across something that 'summed up' my life. Upon my first application of progesterone cream I knew it was right for me. There was no doubt in my mind. Therefore, I am not all that helpful in giving insight in cases where there are just a couple of symptoms.
I will say this however. Using progesterone cream at the levels Dr. Lee suggested is not very risky. If the cream is applied to thinned skin areas with good blood supply, very little progesterone will be stored in fat. This means that a person could 'try it out' with very little risk even if they were not progesterone deficient. If you did try it out and your symptoms responded then I would say you were estrogen dominant and to continue use of PC.
It is very complicated. Yes, it is a hormone and there are some risks, just like with any hormone use. With proper use though, the risks are minimal. Better though to be thoroughly informed before using this.
waxingmoon
Hopeful88
(no login)
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 2 2008, 12:21 AM
What you are describing, about reading a list of symptoms and knowing it isyou is how i feel about the list of androgen symptoms but I have that under control now for quite some time...
Moon
(Login -Moon-)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 2 2008, 9:42 AM
Thank you for your clarifications Waxingmoon! Here's the thing - I have between 9 and 15 symptoms from that list (15 when I include the symptoms from when I wasn't on BCP). But like you said, most of those (especially the ''mental'' ones) are also symptoms of other disorders. On the other hand, I answer to most others with ''don't know'' and for many I'm too young to show. I answer to only 3 with definite no. One last question - if I was to try a progesterone targeting routine, which one do you think it would be better to go with - PC or vitex?
waxingmoon
(Login waxingmoon)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 2 2008, 5:55 PM
Moon,
If you are currently on BCP then the progesterone cream would probably not work for you. The artificial progestins of the BCP will block the receptors from the PC and you would likely have no benefit or little benefit.
The vitex however would be a good choice because it would promote the production of progesterone in your body. There would still be some competition between progestins and your body's progesterone, but you may be able to make headway with this better than PC.
If you are not on BCP, I still think vitex might be the better choice since your symptoms are not as abundant. It will take about 3 months for the vitex to begin to have a notable effect, but it should improve some symptoms. You would not have as much immediate effect, but I have never found a reference that indicated you could ever create too much progesterone by using vitex - therefore this route probably is safer.
waxingmoon
Moon
(Login -Moon-)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 2 2008, 9:43 PM
Thanks Waxingmoon! I have been considering vitex for a while, will probably give it a go sometime later on.
Hopeful88
(Login Hopeful88)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 3 2008, 8:04 PM
Vitex I know I can find at my local health stores so I think I will try it sometime later on as well...
Moon
(Login -Moon-)
SENIOR MEMBER
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 3 2008, 9:27 PM
Some people have ''shrunk'' with vitex, but the prevailing opinion is that that is simply getting rid of bloating / water retention. Still some people weren't pleased. But if you don't have much or any lutheal swelling, then you needn't worry.
Jackie
(no login)
?
February 4 2008, 2:57 AM
What does all this mean? BCP, USP, PC... I am quite sure that I am estrogen dominant and I would like to get Progesterone cream but I don't know what kind to get... BCP, PC, etc... And what brand... Could someone please help me?? SO confusing. :[
Woolly Sheep
(Login Boobsrock4life)
Re: Question concerning Progesterone...
February 5 2008, 5:15 PM
Moon, The progesterone i was talking about was the natural one, it came in a blue bottle of some sort and was USP micronized. I think you might have the facts mixed a little bit. Natural progesterone and phytoestrogens dont add to your body's hormone levels. Please do a research on this so you can confirm this, as we even studied this in reproduction in my biology class. These hormones bind to the receptops that your body already has that supposedly your own hormones should bind to, once these hormones bind to them, your body's hormones no longer have any more receptops to bind too and prolonged usuage tricks the anterior pituary gland to stop producing this hormones because it thinks your body already has enough. This is also why when women want to use natural hormones they have to use high doses that are enough to atleast have an effect for NBE, which is another reason why most commercial NBE products dont work, the doses are too small, not that the grade of their herbs, or the herbs themselves are not efficient enough. Look at an example of women who have experienced a large amount of growth in this forum, like Eve and Erica and you see most of their regimen consisted of estrogen, If you use progesterone, it is a well know fact it acts as an antagonist against estrogen, so in any case it is like you are telling your body, please grow my boobs with this estrogen am feeding you, and then at the same time you are feeding it something that says, well dont grow my boobs with this hormone am feeding you.
It is very important that people should understand that themain hormone necessary for NBE is estrogen, but unfortunately estrogen alone is not a very good thing because it can lead to mitosis gone bad, and what is mitosis gone bad? Simply cancer, were your body just keeps reproducing cells on and on and well unfortunately to a certain extent that is what we need our body to do for healthy breast tissue growth. Progesterone however is also important for the shape of the breast and the way the breast forms, i.e making sure it goes through all the tanner stages of growth appropraitely. For women who had stunted growth, it is possible that progesterone could help as they include it in hormone therapy and all, also for women who are estrogen dominant, it could help, because it counteracts the effects of the estrogen dominance to a certain extent, hopefully the healthy level to which it brings the estrogen is efficient enough for breast growth.
This said, everyone is different and people react differently to things, but this is what I have learned so far.
Beth